Shalamar ‎– Circumstantial Evidence

Backing Vocals, Bass – Kayo (4) Backing Vocals, Vocals [Guest Vocalist] – Melvin Edmonds Keyboards – Babyface Vocals [Verse Background Harmonies], Rap – Micki Free Written-By – B.Robinson*, Charles Muldrow, J. Wilson*, Sidney Johnson*

Bass – Kayo (4) Keyboards – Babyface Programmed By – L.A. And Babyface* Written-By – Kenny Nolan

Backing Vocals – Pebbles Producer [Associate], Backing Vocals – Kayo (4) Programmed By – L.A. & Babyface Saxophone – Eddie M (2) Written-By – L.A.*, Sidney Johnson*, Stephen Page (2) Written-By, Backing Vocals, Keyboards – Babyface

Drums, Keyboards, Programmed By – Michael Hightower* Keyboards – "Roman" Jordan* Programmed By – Larry Leeds Written-By, Producer, Bass, Drums, Keyboards – Bernadette Cooper

Bass – Kayo (4) Keyboards – Babyface Programmed By – L.A. & Babyface Written-By – Delisa Davis, Michael Wells (7)

Guitar, Drums, Programmed By [Synthesizer] – Craig Cooper Saxophone – Gerald Albright Written-By, Producer, Bass, Keyboards, Drums – Jerry Peters

Backing Vocals – Dee Bristol Guitar – Babyface, Hami Dair* Rap – Bernadette Cooper Written-By, Keyboards, Bass – Etienne (6)