Skip to content

Social Picks: The Most Underrated Albums of All Time

Dig into the community’s favorite underrated records, featuring releases from Portishead, Stereolab, Blind Melon, and more.

Recently, Discogs asked the community on Instagram what they thought were the most underrated albums of all time. Fans shared everything, from the electronic post-rock sound of Stereolab to Gil Scot-Heron‘s fiery spoken word offerings. After an album was shared in a comment, other fans of that record showed support by “liking” it. The albums with the most “likes” were compiled in a list here.

Explore the most underrated records of all time below.

#1

Pieces Of A Man

Gil-Scot Heron

1971

As well-known as Gil Scott-Heron may seem in music circles, most people aren’t privy to the legacy he created and how it helped influence modern hip-hop. On his studio debut, Pieces of a Man, he blends political awareness with soul, jazz, funk, and blues. Pieces of a Man contains some of Scott-Heron’s most timeless works, like “The Revolution Will Not Be Televised” and “Home is Where the Hatred Is.”

Pieces Of A Man
Gil Scott-Heron
2014
Soul, Jazz
Vinyl, Album, Reissue, 180g
Shop

#2

Portishead

Portishead

1997

When listeners first think of Portishead, they’re most likely to conjure up the dusty grooves of their debut, Dummy, one of trip-hop’s greatest records. Due to the album’s legacy, the group’s self-titled sophomore effort gets lost in conversation. After the sample-heavy approach of Dummy, the trio regrouped for an offering almost void of outside material. Still, the smokey, backroom vibes and spectral storytelling remain.

Portishead
Portishead
2017
Trip Hop
2 x Vinyl, LP, Reissue,
Shop

#3

Ram

Linda McCartney and Paul McCartney

1971

Following the breakup of the Beatles, Paul McCartney struggled to come into his own as a solo artist. While his former band mates penned classics like Imagine and All Things Must Pass, McCartney received critical lashings for his solo work. However, time has been kind to his early solo output, including Ram, the only collaborative album between him and his wife, Linda. Once deemed irreverent and left-field, Ram is now viewed more favorably as a playful, entertaining collection of songs that showcase the Liverpudlian’s lighter side.

Ram
Paul & Linda McCartney
2017
Pop Rock
Vinyl, LP, Reissue, Remastered
Shop

#4

Soup

Blind Melon

1995

As one of the great, underrated bands of the ’90s, Blind Melon‘s most critically acclaimed release, Soup, never received the commercial success it deserved. This dark slice of alternative rock is Blind Melon’s last before the passing of vocalist Shannon Hoon. Complete with plenty of macabre topics, Soup is an emotive tightrope for the singer, balancing the life of rehab, recovery, and bearing witness to a suicide. Still, Blind Melon’s effort has become an “if you know, you know,” a gem from an expansive time in alternative music’s history.

Soup
Blind Melon
2017
Alternative Rock
Vinyl, LP, Reissue, Remastered
Shop

#5

Midnite Vultures

Beck

1999

After achieving commercial success, Beck turned his attention to making what he called a “big, dumb pop record.” Midnite Vultures blends Beck’s coy humor with homage and parody. With irreverent lyrics belted over G-funk and electro instrumentals, the record captures the cheeky, late-night TV vibe that came with the end of the millennium.

Midnite Vultures
Beck
2003
Alternative Rock, Electro, Synth-pop
CD, Reissue
Shop

#6

#7

Spirit Of Eden
Talk Talk
2019
Post Rock, Ambient
Vinyl, LP, Reissue
Shop

#8

Dots And Loops (Expanded Edition)
Stereolab
2019
Indie Rock, Post Rock, Experimental
2 x Vinyl, LP, Reissue
Shop

#9

Machine Gun Etiquette
The Damned
2016
Punk
LP, Black Vinyl, Reissue
Shop

#10

The In Sound From Way Out!
Beastie Boys
2017
Hip Hop, Jazz, Funk / Soul, Instrumental, Jazzy Hip-Hop, Funk
Vinyl, Compilation, Reissue
Shop

#11

Bubblegum
Mark Lanegan Band
2015
Rock, Alternative Rock, Folk Rock
Vinyl, LP, Album, Reissue
Shop

#12

With Sympathy
Ministry
2019
Electronic, Pop, New Wave, Electro, Synth-pop
Vinyl, Album, Reissue
Shop

#13

Perfect From Now On
Built To Spill
2020
Indie Rock
2 x Vinyl, LP, Reissue
Shop

#14

Sky Blue Sky
Wilco
2023
Alternative Rock, Country Rock
2 x Vinyl, LP, Limited, Repress
Shop

#15

Dear Science
TV On The Radio
2008
Leftfield, Indie Rock
2 x Vinyl, LP
Shop

#16

Begborrowsteel
Count Bass D
2003
Hip Hop
2 x Vinyl
Shop

#17

Lost In The Dream
War On Drugs, The
2014
Rock, Indie Rock
2 x Vinyl, LP, Album, Stereo

#18

Vivid
Living Colour
2024
Alternative Rock, Funk Metal
Vinyl, LP, Reissue
Shop

#19

So Red The Rose
Arcadia
1985
Pop Rock, Synth-pop
Vinyl, LP, Stereo
Shop

#20

Back In The USA
MC5
2003
Rock
Vinyl
Shop

#21

Inside Story
Grace Jones
1986
Funk, Synth-pop
Vinyl, LP
Shop

#22

Straight Up
Badfinger
1971
Power Pop, Pop Rock
Vinyl, LP, Stereo
Shop

#23

Strange Times
The Chameleons
1986
Indie Rock, Alternative Rock
Vinyl, LP, Vinyl, LP, Limited
Shop

#24

A Series Of Sneaks
Spoon
2020
Indie Rock
Vinyl, LP, Reissue, Remastered
Shop

#25

The Magnolia Electric Co
Songs: Ohia
2013
Country Rock
Vinyl, Album, Reissue
Shop

For the month of July, Discogs collaborated with the vinyl community to showcase underrated albums. Check out the community’s picks and share your own with #UnderratedWithDiscogs. Be sure to follow Discogs’ Instagram for new monthly challenges.

KEEP DIGGING

15 Essential Post-Punk Albums

15 Essential Post-Punk Albums

From the angular attack of Gang of Four to the gloomy sounds of The Cure, explore essential post-punk albums from the ’70s and ’80s.
×