DarkPoet

Primal Scream - Give Out But Don't Give Up DarkPoet

8 novembre 2015
edité over 3 years ago
en référence à Give Out But Don't Give Up, CD, Album, CRECD 146
Can anyone tell me where the title of the last track has been gleaned from? I've never seen a version of this album with it actually named; it's not even listed as a track on the tracklistings on any version I'm aware of. Has it just been arbitrarily given a name? In which case, should it not really be listed as 'Untitled track'?
DarkPoet

Primal Scream - Give Out But Don't Give Up DarkPoet

4 janvier 2019
en référence à Give Out But Don't Give Up, CD, Album, CRECD 146
pyenapple
It isn't a track with no title, it simply isn't listed. If the version matches a titled track on other releases, it does actually have a title. I think that's the difference here.

Yes, that makes sense, as long as it's always mentioned in the notes, in line with RSG §1.7.4.
pyenapple

Primal Scream - Give Out But Don't Give Up pyenapple

2 janvier 2019
en référence à Give Out But Don't Give Up, CD, Album, CRECD 146
It isn't a track with no title, it simply isn't listed. If the version matches a titled track on other releases, it does actually have a title. I think that's the difference here.
DarkPoet

Primal Scream - Give Out But Don't Give Up DarkPoet

2 janvier 2019
en référence à Give Out But Don't Give Up, CD, Album, CRECD 146
I'm happy to accept that the title can be taken from the evidence that it was thus titled on a contemporaneous release, but, whilst you're right, a different version appears on The Original Memphis Recordings, the logic doesn't follow unless we're going to re-title 'I'll Be There For You' as 'Jesus' as well.
I asked the original question because RSG §12.4.1 states that "Tracks with no title should be listed as "Untitled"". Given that, on the majority of releases of this album, the track is not titled, I still think it should be listed as such, but I'm not going to lose sleep over it.
pyenapple

Primal Scream - Give Out But Don't Give Up pyenapple

28 décembre 2018
en référence à Give Out But Don't Give Up, CD, Album, CRECD 146
It's listed on the US CD. And the original version is now on the Memphis Sessions album, as well.
https://www.discogs.com/Primal-Scream-Give-Out-But-Dont-Give-Up/release/1133440