Profile

Since 1954 all vinyl were to be mastered via RIAA EQ. Unfortunately this was not and is not the case. Even today mastering engineers use different EQ's than RIAA to cut the lacquers. The result is a lot of mediocre sounding vinyl. To me (an only vinyl listener) is frustrating.
One step in changing this situation (I'm taking other steps also, hopefully more effective ones) is rating the vinyl according to this (RIAA vs non-RIAA). So I'm using the following pattern: Hope it will be useful.

Other than RIAA mastering (all ratings after using the correct EQ on each one of them)
1 star = Very poor sound quality or two or more EQ's were used (non of them RIAA - very rare)
2 stars = Good sound quality
3 stars = Exceptional sound quality or 2 different EQ's used (one of them is RIAA - very rare)

RIAA mastering
4 stars
5 stars = Exceptional sound quality

Evaluation phono EQ's via the Clearaudio Phono Statement.

Where we could possibly find 2 or more EQ's:
1. Box set, if they contain various albums
2. Compilations (most probably when the tracks were taken from vinyl and not from master tapes)
3. Reissues of the pre-RIAA era (they didn't bother to find the correct EQ)
4. Different person cut the lacquer on different sides
5. I don't want to comment on that because I'll be very rude

Recent Activity

Action Description
Puccini* / Maria Callas, Eugenio Fernandi, Elisabeth Schwarzkopf, Giuseppe Nessi, Nicola Zaccaria, Mario Borriello, Renato Ercolani, Piero De Palma, Giulio Mauri, Coro* Et Orchestra Del Teatro Alla Scala Di Milano*, Tullio Serafin - Turandot
submitted Puccini* / Maria Callas, Eugenio Fernandi, Elisabeth Schwarzkopf, Giuseppe Nessi, Nicola Zaccaria, Mario Borriello, Renato Ercolani, Piero De Palma, Giulio Mauri, Coro* Et Orchestra Del Teatro Alla Scala Di Milano*, Tullio Serafin - Turandot. 26 days ago
Antonio Vivaldi / Academy Of St.Martin-In-The-Fields*, Neville Marriner* - La Stravaganza (12 Concerti Op. 4)
submitted Antonio Vivaldi / Academy Of St.Martin-In-The-Fields*, Neville Marriner* - La Stravaganza (12 Concerti Op. 4). about 1 month ago
Ludwig van Beethoven, Emil Gilels - Klaviersonaten • Piano Sonatas
submitted Ludwig van Beethoven, Emil Gilels - Klaviersonaten • Piano Sonatas "Les Adieux" Op. 81a • Op. 79 • Op. 90. 2 months ago
Hector Berlioz - Boston Symphony Orchestra, Seiji Ozawa - Symphonie Fantastique
submitted Hector Berlioz - Boston Symphony Orchestra, Seiji Ozawa - Symphonie Fantastique . 2 months ago
Smetana*, Boston Symphony Orchestra, Rafael Kubelik - Má Vlast
submitted Smetana*, Boston Symphony Orchestra, Rafael Kubelik - Má Vlast. 2 months ago
Franz Schubert – Emil Gilels • Amadeus-Quartett • Rainer Zepperitz - Forellenquintett • Trout Quintet • Quintetto »La Trota«
posted a review of Franz Schubert – Emil Gilels • Amadeus-Quartett • Rainer Zepperitz - Forellenquintett • Trout Quintet • Quintetto »La Trota«. 4 months ago
"Some records do appear to sound better played back with different equalisation settings. But it doesn’t mean they were recorded using those settings"

We are talking about phono EQ not any equalisation they are very specific (eg DECCA, CCIR, IEC,... See full review
Jefferson Airplane - Surrealistic Pillow
submitted Jefferson Airplane - Surrealistic Pillow. 4 months ago
Beethoven* – Wiener Philharmoniker, Carlos Kleiber - Symphonie Nr. 7 A-dur op 92
posted a review of Beethoven* – Wiener Philharmoniker, Carlos Kleiber - Symphonie Nr. 7 A-dur op 92. 4 months ago
"The session was recorded to tape equalized to the CCIR standard. When played back (for the downmixing and mastering)
the CCIR equalization is reversed"

But did they reverse it? And why they recorded it via CCIR, for what purpose? The tape recorder... See full review
Beethoven* – Wiener Philharmoniker, Carlos Kleiber - Symphonie Nr. 7 A-dur op 92
posted a review of Beethoven* – Wiener Philharmoniker, Carlos Kleiber - Symphonie Nr. 7 A-dur op 92. 4 months ago
Try CCIR and we will discuss it. Don't put your arm in the fire that is RIAA. This CCIR is about the mastering or the laquer, who knows. To my experience the case is more complicate. We have reissues with the same EQ as the original and reissues with... See full review
Led Zeppelin - The Soundtrack From The Film The Song Remains The Same
posted a review of Led Zeppelin - The Soundtrack From The Film The Song Remains The Same. 4 months ago
Led Zeppelin - The Soundtrack From The Film The Song Remains The Same (B) vs Led Zeppelin - The Soundtrack From The Film The Song Remains The Same (A) .
Side A: all tracks are much better on (A) (more space, air and soundstage, bigger instruments, and the voice is more intergrated and distinguishable).
Side B: (B) is better than (A) after all the 1.5 sides in which... See full review
Franz Schubert – Emil Gilels • Amadeus-Quartett • Rainer Zepperitz - Forellenquintett • Trout Quintet • Quintetto »La Trota«
posted a review of Franz Schubert – Emil Gilels • Amadeus-Quartett • Rainer Zepperitz - Forellenquintett • Trout Quintet • Quintetto »La Trota«. 5 months ago
Yes, I checked Franz Schubert – Emil Gilels • Amadeus-Quartett • Rainer Zepperitz - Forellenquintett • Trout Quintet • Quintetto »La Trota«. It was also CCIR with inferior sound quality. "Mixed by Rainer Maillard & cut by Sidney C. Meyer directly from original analogue source". Tested in 3 systems with the same result.
Couldn't find on the LP the word... See full review
Beethoven* – Wiener Philharmoniker, Carlos Kleiber - Symphonie Nr. 7 A-dur op 92
posted a review of Beethoven* – Wiener Philharmoniker, Carlos Kleiber - Symphonie Nr. 7 A-dur op 92. 5 months ago
First: I don't review interpretations I just want to say that this one is concidered the best 7th (I prefer Teodor Currentzis, Ludwig van Beethoven, Musicaeterna - Beethoven Symphony No. 7 In A Major Op.92)
Second: Again (as Franz Schubert – Emil Gilels • Amadeus-Quartett • Rainer Zepperitz - Forellenquintett • Trout Quintet • Quintetto »La Trota«) has been mastered via CCIR (see insert). So when listened via RIAA it sounds without air and punch... See full review
Franz Schubert – Emil Gilels • Amadeus-Quartett • Rainer Zepperitz - Forellenquintett • Trout Quintet • Quintetto »La Trota«
posted a review of Franz Schubert – Emil Gilels • Amadeus-Quartett • Rainer Zepperitz - Forellenquintett • Trout Quintet • Quintetto »La Trota«. 5 months ago
Does your soundstage has the "usual" height? Please try listen also via Teldec or Columbia you will find that the soundstage is similar (very low height). This is not normal, when you use the correct phono EQ you will "see" an open soundstage. If you... See full review
Franz Schubert – Emil Gilels • Amadeus-Quartett • Rainer Zepperitz - Forellenquintett • Trout Quintet • Quintetto »La Trota«
posted a review of Franz Schubert – Emil Gilels • Amadeus-Quartett • Rainer Zepperitz - Forellenquintett • Trout Quintet • Quintetto »La Trota«. 5 months ago
As you can see from the insert this LP had been mastered via IEC/CCIR. In fact is CCIR (tested).How on earth could possibly sound good when plaied via a standard (RIAA) phono stage?. The soundstage height is short, every instrument is very agressive... See full review
Various - 45 Years Excellence Edition Volume 1
submitted Various - 45 Years Excellence Edition Volume 1. 6 months ago
Magazine - The Correct Use Of Soap
posted a review of Magazine - The Correct Use Of Soap. 12 months ago
Better avoid it. Don't know how the others sound but this one has been mastered via CCIR eq and not RIAA so it sounds with out air, the bass is a little muffled and with a short soundstage.
The Velvet Underground - 1969
submitted The Velvet Underground - 1969. about 1 year ago
submitted Georg Philipp Telemann - 2 Konzerte Für Trompete / 2 Quartette. about 1 year ago
submitted Walter Gerwig - Französische Lautenmusik Der Renaissance. about 1 year ago
Various - Fictions
submitted Various - Fictions. about 1 year ago
submitted Mozart*, Karajan* - La Flûte Enchantée. about 1 year ago
Friedrich II. von Preussen* — Hans-Martin Linde · Jörg Ewald Dähler · Hannelore Müller - Schola Cantorum Basiliensis · August Wenzinger - Gerhard Unger · Ensemble Musica Antiqua, Wien* · René Clemencic - Flötenkonzert · Flötensonate · Preussische Grenadierlieder Und Märsche Aus Friderizianischer Zeit
submitted Friedrich II. von Preussen* — Hans-Martin Linde · Jörg Ewald Dähler · Hannelore Müller - Schola Cantorum Basiliensis · August Wenzinger - Gerhard Unger · Ensemble Musica Antiqua, Wien* · René Clemencic - Flötenkonzert · Flötensonate · Preussische Grenadierlieder Und Märsche Aus Friderizianischer Zeit. about 1 year ago
Strawinsky*, Borodin*, Mussorgsky* - Feuervogel-Suite / Polowetzer Tänze / Eine Nacht Auf Dem Kahlen Berge
submitted Strawinsky*, Borodin*, Mussorgsky* - Feuervogel-Suite / Polowetzer Tänze / Eine Nacht Auf Dem Kahlen Berge. about 1 year ago
Various - Musik Des Mittelalters Und Der Renaissance
submitted Various - Musik Des Mittelalters Und Der Renaissance. about 1 year ago
Hawkwind - Quark, Strangeness And Charm
submitted Hawkwind - Quark, Strangeness And Charm. about 1 year ago
Gaucelm Faidit : Kecskés Ensemble, András L. Kecskés* - Songs. Troubadour Music From The 12th-13th Centuries
submitted Gaucelm Faidit : Kecskés Ensemble, András L. Kecskés* - Songs. Troubadour Music From The 12th-13th Centuries. about 1 year ago
submitted Iuventus Paedagogica, Musica Bohemica - Hej, Hej, Koleda - Vánoční Písně Z Podkrkonoší. about 1 year ago
Felt - The Strange Idols Pattern And Other Short Stories
submitted Felt - The Strange Idols Pattern And Other Short Stories. about 1 year ago
Miles Davis - Sketches Of Spain
submitted Miles Davis - Sketches Of Spain. about 1 year ago
Durutti Column* - Sunlight To Blue...Blue To Blackness
submitted Durutti Column* - Sunlight To Blue...Blue To Blackness. about 1 year ago
Various - Liebersfreud / Songs My Mother Taught Me
submitted Various - Liebersfreud / Songs My Mother Taught Me. about 1 year ago
Bartok* - Gershwin*, Seiji Ozawa, Boston Symphony Orchestra, The San Francisco Symphony Orchestra - Music For Strings, Percussion And Celesta • An American In Paris
submitted Bartok* - Gershwin*, Seiji Ozawa, Boston Symphony Orchestra, The San Francisco Symphony Orchestra - Music For Strings, Percussion And Celesta • An American In Paris. about 1 year ago
submitted Bad Lieutenant (3) - Sink Or Swim. about 1 year ago
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart - Die Schönsten Sinfonien Nr. 25, 28, 29, 33, 38, 39, 40 Und 41
submitted Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart - Die Schönsten Sinfonien Nr. 25, 28, 29, 33, 38, 39, 40 Und 41. about 1 year ago
Shostakovich* - Kiril Kondrashin, Moscow Philharmonic* - Symphony No. 5
submitted Shostakovich* - Kiril Kondrashin, Moscow Philharmonic* - Symphony No. 5. about 1 year ago
Blurt - Cut It!
submitted Blurt - Cut It!. about 1 year ago
Tom Verlaine - Warm And Cool
submitted Tom Verlaine - Warm And Cool. over 2 years ago
Conflict (2) - It's Time To See Who's Who
submitted Conflict (2) - It's Time To See Who's Who. over 2 years ago
Gavin Friday & The Man Seezer* - Each Man Kills The Thing He Loves
submitted Gavin Friday & The Man Seezer* - Each Man Kills The Thing He Loves. over 2 years ago
The Album Leaf - In A Safe Place
submitted The Album Leaf - In A Safe Place. over 2 years ago
Collegium Musicum Pragense, František Rössler-Rosetti*, František Stamic, František Stamic, Leopold Koželuh, Ondřej Anton, Josef Fiala (2) - Czech Hunting Music In World Archives
submitted Collegium Musicum Pragense, František Rössler-Rosetti*, František Stamic, František Stamic, Leopold Koželuh, Ondřej Anton, Josef Fiala (2) - Czech Hunting Music In World Archives. over 2 years ago
America (2) - History · America's Greatest Hits
submitted America (2) - History · America's Greatest Hits. over 2 years ago
Conrad Paumann ‧ Hans Sachs / Josef Ulsamer ‧ Nürnberger Gambencollegium ‧ Friedrich Brückner-Rüggeberg ‧ Rudolf Aue - 14 Lieder Und Spielstücke Aus Dem Locheimer Liederbuch Und Dem Fundamentum Organisandi Des Conrad Paumann ‧ 5 Lieder
submitted Conrad Paumann ‧ Hans Sachs / Josef Ulsamer ‧ Nürnberger Gambencollegium ‧ Friedrich Brückner-Rüggeberg ‧ Rudolf Aue - 14 Lieder Und Spielstücke Aus Dem Locheimer Liederbuch Und Dem Fundamentum Organisandi Des Conrad Paumann ‧ 5 Lieder. over 2 years ago
Johann Sebastian Bach - Gundula Janowitz, Christa Ludwig, Wiener Singverein, Berliner Philharmoniker, Herbert von Karajan, Peter Schreier, Karl Ridderbusch, Robert Kerns - Messe H-moll, BWV 232
submitted Johann Sebastian Bach - Gundula Janowitz, Christa Ludwig, Wiener Singverein, Berliner Philharmoniker, Herbert von Karajan, Peter Schreier, Karl Ridderbusch, Robert Kerns - Messe H-moll, BWV 232. over 2 years ago
Bartók* / Reiner* / Chicago Symphony* - Music For Strings, Percussion And Celesta / Hungarian Sketches
submitted Bartók* / Reiner* / Chicago Symphony* - Music For Strings, Percussion And Celesta / Hungarian Sketches. over 2 years ago
City (3) - City
submitted City (3) - City. over 2 years ago
Robert Stolz Und Heinz Hoppe - Galakonzert Mit Robert Stolz
submitted Robert Stolz Und Heinz Hoppe - Galakonzert Mit Robert Stolz. over 2 years ago
Clemencic Consort Direction René Clemencic - Carmina Burana 1 (Version Originale & Integrale)
submitted Clemencic Consort Direction René Clemencic - Carmina Burana 1 (Version Originale & Integrale). over 2 years ago
Bach*, Regina Werner, Heidi Rieß, Hermann Christian Polster, Thomanerchor Leipzig*, Gewandhausorchester Leipzig, Hans-Joachim Rotzsch - Kantaten - Wir Danken Dir, Gott BWV 29, Preise, Jerusalem, Den Herrn  BWV 119
submitted Bach*, Regina Werner, Heidi Rieß, Hermann Christian Polster, Thomanerchor Leipzig*, Gewandhausorchester Leipzig, Hans-Joachim Rotzsch - Kantaten - Wir Danken Dir, Gott BWV 29, Preise, Jerusalem, Den Herrn BWV 119. over 2 years ago
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, Pro Musica Orchester*, Edouard Van Remoortel - Serenade Nr. 9 D-dur KV 320 - Posthornserenade
submitted Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, Pro Musica Orchester*, Edouard Van Remoortel - Serenade Nr. 9 D-dur KV 320 - Posthornserenade. over 2 years ago