Removal of DIY package from other releases as unique release (re-solved)
Started by punkhank over 8 years ago, 15 replies
-
punkhank over 8 years ago
This post is hidden because you reported it for abuse. Show this post punkhank edited over 8 years agoPertti Kurikan Nimipäivät - Sikakovapaketti is made by someone as "a package".
It contains
-The Punk Syndrome - Kovasikajuttu DVD (documentary not on database in Discogs)
http://www.pkn.rocks/film/
- Pertti Kurikan Nimipäivät - Kuus Kuppia Kahvia... Ja Yks Kokis
- cassette by artist other than Pertti Kurikan Nimipäivät (Pentti Kurikan Nimipäivät)
- some merchandise as said on notes
Should it be removed or edited as suggested by me?
http://www.discogs.com/history?release=4917293#latest
Are these kind of self-made packages allowed here in Discogs? -
cellularsmoke over 8 years ago
This post is hidden because you reported it for abuse. Show this postWho put the package together? Band? Label? If neither of those, it's not eligible... -
punkhank over 8 years ago
This post is hidden because you reported it for abuse. Show this postI was told that it was put together by documentary group as Christmas present package for charity purposes and sold mainly on The Punk Syndrome facebook on Xmas 2012. So not put together by the band nor record label. -
cellularsmoke over 8 years ago
This post is hidden because you reported it for abuse. Show this postTo me, that's similar to a Retailer putting together a bunch of merch in a package as a promotion, not official, and not eligible for the database. Others may have a different thought. -
punkhank over 8 years ago
This post is hidden because you reported it for abuse. Show this postThanks for your opinions cellularsmoke. I'll wait for some other opinions until put on removal voting. -
The_Beatles. over 8 years ago
This post is hidden because you reported it for abuse. Show this postpunkhank
So not put together by the band nor record label.
cellularsmoke
To me, that's similar to a Retailer putting together a bunch of merch in a package as a promotion, not official, and not eligible for the database.
Not eligible. -
punkhank over 8 years ago
This post is hidden because you reported it for abuse. Show this postPending removal: http://www.discogs.com/history?release=4917293#latest
Not eligble per discussion. -
avalon67 over 8 years ago
This post is hidden because you reported it for abuse. Show this postAre the recordings available otherwise? -
avalon67 over 8 years ago
This post is hidden because you reported it for abuse. Show this postOK read the OP properly, but I still think this needs more discussion,. -
punkhank over 8 years ago
This post is hidden because you reported it for abuse. Show this postRemoved as voted. Case closed. -
avalon67 over 8 years ago
This post is hidden because you reported it for abuse. Show this postIn less than 20 hours? Why open a thread? Two people agreeing is hardly a consensus ;) -
punkhank over 8 years ago
This post is hidden because you reported it for abuse. Show this postat least five users with voting abitility voted yes for removal within few hours -
punkhank over 8 years ago
This post is hidden because you reported it for abuse. Show this post punkhank edited over 8 years agoSame "package" submitted again, even has the image of mailer. Only named differently. I put it for removal vote, please vote yes: https://www.discogs.com/release/8242208-Kovasikajuttu/history#latest -
punkhank over 8 years ago
This post is hidden because you reported it for abuse. Show this postRemoved, case closed again. -
rockingfood over 8 years ago
This post is hidden because you reported it for abuse. Show this postApologize for the late arrival of the answer. The band has made these record company representation. Happy Spring :) -
punkhank over 8 years ago
This post is hidden because you reported it for abuse. Show this postrockingfood
Apologize for the late arrival of the answer. The band has made these record company representation. Happy Spring :)
Unfortunately these kind of bundles are not eligble for unique release per this discussion and Discogs guidelines too. Happy spring to you too :)
Log In You must be logged in to post.